Home Library Translate
A A A
Share »
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on LinkedIn
Connect »

Blog: Leadership

Menu

  • This Blog's Home
  • Guest Writer Submissions
  • Policies
  • To Subscribe to a Blog
  • About
  • Feedback

Is Transformational Leadership Overly Heroic?

By Steve Wolinski on May 22, 2010

In Cater McNamara’s blog entry from earlier this week (“Are we Really Just Looking for Leaders to Save Us from Ourselves?”) he asks how much consultants are fantasizing when they come up with all the “wondrous traits” that the leaders of today are supposed to possess.   I am not sure if it is fantasy, but certainly agree that it is not based in reality.  I would like to keep in mind this question (i.e. is it fantasy?) in mind as we explore the theory of transformational leadership. 

Introduction to Transformational Leadership

James MacGrgeor Burns was the first to talk about transformational (and transactional) leadership theory in 1978.  It is relatively evident to me that the research, training, and academic teaching on transformational leadership have outpaced that of any other theory of leadership in the past twenty-eight years.  There is an interesting phenomenon in the way that transformational leadership is almost never discussed, at least not at length, without differentiating it from transactional leadership.  I will lend support to this claim by doing just that.   

What is Transactional Leadership?

Transactional leadership is grounded in the notion that leaders lead through social exchange.  That is, they offer rewards to followers, financial and otherwise, for meeting productivity and performance standards, and withhold rewards to followers if productivity and performance are considered deficient.  These transactions are established by leaders specifying with followers the rewards that are available for meeting expectations. 

What is Transformational Leadership?

The theory of transformational leadership views the transactional leadership style as appropriate in certain circumstances, and even as an extension of transformational leadership, but believes leaders must also attend to the sense of self-worth of followers and the garnering of full-fledged commitment to individual, team, and organizational objectives. 

In conducting a quick scan of the literature the following attributes and qualities of transformational leaders emerged: charismatic, inspirational, challenging, persuasive, intellectually stimulating, considerate, supportive, respected, risk-taker, coach, mentor, consistent, ethical, enthusiastic, encouraging, and personable.   It is a long laundry list of worthwhile qualities and roles.  But does it cross some line, intimated by Carter, which has the theory flirting with foolishness?  I say “yes”, “no”, “maybe”.  In my mind it depends on whose version of transformational leadership you embrace.  I like the way that Bass delineates the main components by stating that transformational leaders should:

  • Inspire followers to extraordinary performance and to a shared sense of commitment to a vision for the organization
  • Encourage and challenge followers to be creative and innovative in their efforts to solve organizational problems
  • Focus on the development of the leadership skills of others through coaching, mentoring, and other forms of support

Conclusion

While the proponents of transformational leadership, of which there are many, may excessively romanticize the theory at times, it is my opinion that the central components of the theory are just tangible and relevant enough to make it a valid and valuable leadership model.  In future blogs a more in-depth description and analysis of transformational leadership will be provided.  In the meantime, what are your thoughts?  Is it too much, too little, or just right?

« Previous Next »

Search Our Site

Meet the Blog’s Hosts

Carol Mase, President of Cairn Consultants, is an educator and coach-consultant who has worked in global marketing, strategic planning, and large scale organizational change. [Read more ...]


Kristin Keffeler, MSM, of Kinetic Enterprise, is a business development and leadership coach who specializes in supporting entrepreneurs and business leaders to bring their Big Ideas to life.
[Read more ...]


Dr. Steven Ober is a senior executive coach and consultant. He has worked successfully with executives and managers in high tech, business and industry, health care, government, and education.
[Read more ...]


Recent Blog Posts

  • What kind of a Tough Leader are you?
  • Unleashing the Power of your Story: Creating a New Leadership Story
  • Unleashing the Power of your Story: Working with your Story
  • Unleashing the Power of your Story: Leadership and the Hero’s Journey
  • Expanding awareness
  • Pathways for Leaders
  • Unleashing the Power of your Story : The Larger Context – Ideas and Meaning
  • Mirror, Mirror on the Wall…
  • Embedding the Ethos of Community: Moonshot #2
  • Mending the Soul

Categories

  • Boards of Directors
  • Change
  • Chief Executive Officer
  • Civic Leadership
  • General Resources
  • Guiding Others
  • Leadership
  • Leadership Theories
  • Leading Groups
  • Leading Organizations
  • Leading Others
  • Leading Yourself
  • management
  • Missions, Visions, Values
  • Power and Influence
  • Supervision
  • Uncategorized

Related Library Topics

  • Boards of Directors
  • Chief Executive Role
  • Continuous Learning
  • Creativity and Innovation
  • Decision Making
  • Ethics
  • Leadership (Overview)
  • Leading Groups
  • Leading Organizations
  • Leading People
  • Leading Yourself
  • Management
  • Organizational Change
  • Planning
  • Power and Influence
  • Problem Solving
  • Sustainable Development
  • Systems Thinking

Library's Blogs

  • Boards of Directors
  • Building a Business
  • Business Communications
  • Business Ethics, Culture and Performance
  • Business Planning
  • Career Management
  • Coaching and Action Learning
  • Consulting and Organizational Development
  • Crisis Management
  • Customer Service
  • Facilitation
  • Free Management Library Blogs
  • Fundraising for Nonprofits
  • Human Resources
  • Leadership
  • Marketing and Social Media
  • Nonprofit Capacity Building
  • Project Management
  • Quality Management
  • Social Enterprise
  • Spirituality
  • Strategic Planning
  • Supervision
  • Team Building and Performance
  • Training and Development
About Feedback Legal Privacy Policy Contact Us
Free Management Library, © Copyright Authenticity Consulting, LLC ®; All rights reserved.
  • Graphics by Wylde Hare LLC
  • Website maintained by Caitlin Cahill

By continuing to use this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.X