Home Library Translate
A A A
Share »
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on LinkedIn
Connect »

Blog: Boards of Directors

Menu

  • This Blog's Home
  • Guest Writer Submissions
  • Policies
  • To Subscribe to a Blog
  • About
  • Feedback

Dangerous ideas made safe

By Julie Garland McLellan on October 11, 2010

Boards need to discuss horrible ideas: the idea that your product might no longer be relevant to your target market, the idea that your staff might prefer to work elsewhere, or that your technology might leave you unable to deliver goods and services. These are not issues that management like to talk about and, indeed, when we are being honest these issues scare directors as well as executives. But we do need to talk about them.

A recent failure in IT service left an airline unable to fly because it could not book passengers on to flights, work out where its planes were, or roster crews to work. The booking platform had been outsourced and the failure breached the service level provided under the outsourcing contract. Now journalists are reporting that the resulting damages may bankrupt the IT service company and the airline is struggling to reassure potential passengers that they can be relied upon; not an easy task when for several days the news headlines were about executives missing meetings, families unable to return from holidays and brides unable to attend their own weddings.

The key question of ‘what will happen if the technology fails’ had been asked and answered with assurances of back up sites, time limits on outages and other comforting facts. These assurances proved false. Did something stop the board from asking questions that might have revealed that the assurances were not deliverable under the arrangement as implemented?

Was it a lack of understanding of the importance of a booking system to an airline? I don’t think so.

Could it have been that the board were totally trusting of IT suppliers who had never before failed in any way? I doubt it.

Or was it that, having asked a good question and received a satisfactory answer, the board conversation quickly moved on? Could directors have been uncomfortable with pursuing the idea of what a total failure would mean?

Boards need to be places where uncomfortable conversations happen. A recent harassment case was followed by a spate of embarrassing remarks such as ‘we always knew he was a party guy’ or ‘everyone knew he liked the ladies’. Why did the board not consider the implications of these gems of knowledge? With hindsight it all seems so predictable. Why was it too hard to apply foresight?

Occasionally boards discuss issues that dramatically affect the future of the company. It is imperative that directors speak up and follow their trains of thought to the most uncomfortable destinations, as well as to the most likely, or most profitable ones. Questions such as ‘What is the worst thing that can go wrong’ should receive several considered answers, from the board, management or specialist advisers. Mitigation or avoidance strategies can only be designed if the underlying events have been deemed possible.

As directors we must tackle the dangerous ideas in a safe environment; before we ever encounter them in real life. We need to allow thoughts to wander to the darkest outcomes and to contemplate with serious intent exactly how much we are willing to risk on each strategic venture. The trouble is, we often find it hard to give voice to these thoughts for fear of being perceived as unhelpful, unsupportive, or biased against the proponent of each strategy.

Chairmen can help by encouraging their boards to spend more time on the potential downsides than they do on the potential upsides.  Only when it is safe to discuss the unspeakable horror of adverse outcomes will it be possible to avoid them.

What do you think?

———————————————————————————————————-
Julie Garland-McLellan has been internationally acclaimed as a leading expert on board governance.  See her website and LinkedIn profiles, and get her book Dilemmas, Dilemmas: Practical Case Studies for Company Directors.

« Previous Next »

Search Our Site

Meet this Blog’s Co-Hosts

Carter McNamara of Authenticity Consulting, LLC, provides organization development and consultant training services, and is developer of the Free Management Library. [Read more ...]


Julie Garland-McLellan uses her experience and depth of knowledge in corporate governance to show boards with limited resources how to be more effective through practical governance innovation and know-how.
[Read more ...]


Nick Lindsay of Elemental CoSec, provides corporate governance, legal and company secretarial advice to a wide range of companies in the UK.
[Read more ...]

Recent Blog Posts

  • Will beneficial ownership registers spread around the World?
  • Governing an entrepreneur – a dilemma
  • Can a director serve two interests? – a dilemma
  • When a director knows what isn’t in the papers – a dilemma
  • Should the MD have a vote? – a dilemma
  • Association boards and conflicts of interest – a dilemma
  • Issues for a prospective owner director – a dilemma
  • 51% compliance with the UK Corporate Governance Code
  • 10 Myths About Boards of Directors
  • How to manage excessive demands on time (from a powerful person)? – a dilemma

Categories of Posts

  • Accountabilities, Laws and Ethics
  • Basics and Overviews
  • Basics and Overviews
  • Board Committees
  • Board Evaluations
  • Board Meetings
  • Board Membership
  • Board Training and Dev.
  • General Resources
  • Recurring Activities
  • Roles and Responsibilities
  • Supervising CEO
  • Uncategorized

Related Library Topics

  • Board / Employees Roles
  • Board Basics
  • Board Development
  • Board Models
  • Board Operations
  • Board Policies
  • Board Staffing
  • Board Training
  • Committees
  • Compensation of Members
  • Evaluating the Board
  • Laws and Ethics
  • Meetings
  • Roles and Responsibilities

Library's Blogs

  • Boards of Directors
  • Building a Business
  • Business Communications
  • Business Ethics, Culture and Performance
  • Business Planning
  • Career Management
  • Coaching and Action Learning
  • Consulting and Organizational Development
  • Crisis Management
  • Customer Service
  • Facilitation
  • Free Management Library Blogs
  • Fundraising for Nonprofits
  • Human Resources
  • Leadership
  • Marketing and Social Media
  • Nonprofit Capacity Building
  • Project Management
  • Quality Management
  • Social Enterprise
  • Spirituality
  • Strategic Planning
  • Supervision
  • Team Building and Performance
  • Training and Development
About Feedback Legal Privacy Policy Contact Us
Free Management Library, © Copyright Authenticity Consulting, LLC ®; All rights reserved.
  • Graphics by Wylde Hare LLC
  • Website maintained by Caitlin Cahill

By continuing to use this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.X